Values, pluralism and paradigm physiology

Verdict before critique on a real generative judge

confirmed registered

The reading

  1. the verdict decoded at the pre-critique position matches the final verdict

    verdict_prefix_match_rate >= 0.9 0.6 Verdict before critique on a real generative judge confirmed registered >= 0.9 The frozen study "Verdict before critique on a real generative judge", adjudicated on 19 July 2026 at the registered level of the project's evidence ladder. One frozen study, adjudicated once, on skywork-critic, over judge-pairs-1000. It does not establish that the same holds on another subject, another dataset or another run. Open the record › confirmed

JUDGE-VBC against its frozen predictions: confirmed.
JUDGE-VBC against its frozen predictions: confirmed.

Measurements

flip_rate
Verdict before critique on a real generative judge confirmed registered none registered The frozen study "Verdict before critique on a real generative judge", adjudicated on 19 July 2026 at the registered level of the project's evidence ladder. One frozen study, adjudicated once, on skywork-critic, over judge-pairs-1000. It does not establish that the same holds on another subject, another dataset or another run. Nothing was registered against this value in advance, so it is a supporting measurement rather than a tested one. Open the record ›

Provenance

card
JUDGE-VBC
frozen_at
adjudicated_at
spec_hash
spec:a8172c8c8f19fef678f524a80564dadc
study_id
study:campaign-judge-vbc@v1#a8172c8c